Blog / DiSC basics

Everything DiSC® vs Insights Discovery, CliftonStrengths, Predictive Index and MBTI

4 min read

Everything DiSC vs. Insights, CliftonStrengths, Predictive Index, and MBTI

Organisations that want people to understand each other better usually end up comparing the same five names: Everything DiSC®, Insights Discovery, CliftonStrengths, the Predictive Index and the MBTI®. They are often treated as interchangeable. They are not. Each was built for a different job, and choosing the wrong one is the most common reason an assessment ends up in a drawer.

We are an authorised Everything DiSC® partner, so we are not neutral. This comparison sticks to what each tool is designed for, so you can decide what fits your goal.

At a glance

AssessmentWhat it describesModelBuilt forNot built for
Everything DiSC®Behaviour at work and how to work with each colleague4 styles, 12 blended styles on a circleTeams, managers, communication, salesHiring decisions
Insights DiscoveryPreferences shown as four colour energiesBased on Jung’s psychological typesSelf-awareness and team communicationHiring decisions
CliftonStrengthsNatural talents34 themes in four domainsStrengths-based developmentDescribing how two people should work together
Predictive IndexBehavioural drives at work4 factors, 17 reference profilesHiring and managing peopleOpen-ended self-reflection in workshops
MBTI®Personality preferences4 preference pairs, 16 typesPersonal insight and coachingHiring decisions

Everything DiSC®

Everything DiSC® describes how people behave at work: how fast they move, how much they question, and what they prioritise. It places each person as a dot on a circle with four basic styles (D, i, S and C) and 12 blended styles. The questionnaire is adaptive: when answers on a scale are unclear, it asks more questions about that scale. It takes 15 to 20 minutes.

Its strength is practical use between colleagues. The reports and the Catalyst™ platform show each person how to work with a specific colleague, and different profiles cover managers, sales, conflict, emotional intelligence and leadership. Its scales show test-retest reliability of .85 to .88, and Everything DiSC® Workplace is certified by DNV to the EFPA test-quality standard. It is designed for development, not selection. The research behind DiSC.

Insights Discovery

Insights Discovery is published by Insights Learning and Development and is based on Carl Jung’s psychological types. It describes preferences as four colour energies (Fiery Red, Sunshine Yellow, Earth Green and Cool Blue), which many people find easy to remember. Like DiSC, it is mainly used for self-awareness and team communication, delivered by licensed practitioners.

Compared with DiSC: both give teams a simple, shared language. The main differences are the underlying model (Jung’s types for Insights, observable behaviour for DiSC) and the ecosystem: Everything DiSC® has separate profiles for managers, sales, conflict and leadership, and a platform for comparing yourself with any colleague.

CliftonStrengths

CliftonStrengths, from Gallup, identifies a person’s natural talents across 34 themes, grouped into four domains: executing, influencing, relationship building and strategic thinking. Most people work with their top five themes. The philosophy is to build on what people do best rather than fix weaknesses.

Compared with DiSC: CliftonStrengths is strong for individual development and engagement. Because there are 34 themes and countless combinations, it is less direct about how two specific people should communicate. Many organisations use both: CliftonStrengths for personal development, DiSC for how people work together.

Predictive Index

The Predictive Index Behavioral Assessment is a short, free-choice adjective checklist that measures four factors: dominance, extraversion, patience and formality. Results are grouped into 17 reference profiles. It is typically used with the PI Cognitive Assessment and a job target, as part of a hiring and talent platform.

Compared with DiSC: the Predictive Index is built with hiring in mind, while Everything DiSC® is built for development and is not used for selection. If you need an assessment for recruitment, look at a tool designed for that decision. We offer ProfileXT®, which compares candidates with a performance model for the role.

MBTI®

The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator® describes personality preferences on four pairs (extraversion or introversion, sensing or intuition, thinking or feeling, judging or perceiving), which combine into 16 types. It is published by The Myers-Briggs Company and is widely used in coaching and personal development. Its publisher states that it should not be used for hiring.

Compared with DiSC: the MBTI® describes inner preferences and how people take in information and make decisions. DiSC focuses on observable behaviour at work and gives concrete tips for working with each colleague, which makes it quicker to apply in a team session. Researchers have also questioned how consistently people get the same type when they retake the MBTI®, while Everything DiSC® publishes its test-retest results.

How to choose

  • A shared language for a team or the whole organisation: Everything DiSC® or Insights Discovery. Choose DiSC if you want separate profiles for managers, sales and conflict, and a platform people keep using.
  • Strengths-based personal development: CliftonStrengths.
  • Hiring and internal moves: an assessment built for selection, such as ProfileXT® or the Predictive Index. Never a development tool such as DiSC or the MBTI®.
  • Individual coaching on personality preferences: the MBTI®, or Everything DiSC® when the coaching is about working relationships.
  • A team that struggles with trust and accountability: The Five Behaviors®, which builds DiSC into a team programme.

Questions to ask before you choose any assessment

  • Is it designed for development or for selection, and does the publisher say so?
  • Are reliability and validity published, and has it been reviewed independently?
  • Will people still use it after the workshop, or is the report read once?
  • Does it help two specific people work together, or only describe individuals?
  • Where is the data stored, and will the provider sign a Data Processing Agreement?
  • What does it cost per person, and what does certification cost if you want to run it yourself?

Comparing assessments for your organisation? We are happy to talk through the options, including when DiSC is not the right tool.

What is DiSC? → Talk to us →